loader

Top Mistakes to Avoid When Buying an Umbrella Insurance Policy in Pennsylvania

Nov 12, 2025

Umbrella Insurance

Top Mistakes to Avoid When Buying an Umbrella Insurance Policy in Pennsylvania

Having the right insurance coverage can make a big difference in the event of unexpected events. Many people in Pennsylvania buy umbrella insurance without fully understanding how it works, leading to gaps in coverage or missed benefits. To help you make a wise decision, let’s look at the mistakes to avoid when buying umbrella insurance in Pennsylvania and how you can protect your financial future.

  • Not Understanding What Umbrella Insurance Covers: One of the most common errors is not knowing precisely what umbrella insurance covers in Pennsylvania. Many assume it’s only for the wealthy, but that’s not true. Umbrella insurance offers extra liability protection on top of your home, auto, or renters insurance.

    This coverage helps when your existing policy limits are used up due to accidents, injuries, or lawsuits. It can cover legal fees, property damage, or even situations where you’re held responsible for someone’s injury. Knowing what your policy includes helps you avoid surprises during a claim.

  • Choosing the Wrong Coverage Limit: Selecting the right amount of coverage is just as important as buying the policy itself. Some people underestimate how much protection they need and choose a lower limit to save money. However, this can leave your assets exposed in the event of a serious accident or lawsuit.

    It’s essential to understand how to choose the correct coverage limit for umbrella insurance. Consider your total assets, your home, vehicles, savings, and future income potential. The coverage amount should be enough to protect everything you’ve worked hard for. A quick conversation with an experienced insurance advisor can help you calculate the correct limit for your situation.

  • Ignoring Underlying Policy Requirements: Umbrella insurance doesn’t replace your primary auto insurance or homeowners insurance, it extends their protection. Most insurers require you to maintain a specific amount of coverage on those base policies for your umbrella policy to apply. If your primary coverage doesn’t meet those limits, your umbrella insurance might not activate during a claim.

    Before finalizing your policy, confirm that your underlying coverage meets the insurer’s requirements. Doing this ensures your umbrella protection works as intended.

  • Forgetting to Include All Family Members or Drivers: Another mistake many people make is not listing every driver or household member on their policy. If someone who lives with you gets into an accident and isn’t covered under your umbrella policy, you might not receive the full benefit of your protection.

    Always review who is covered, especially if you have new drivers in the family or multiple vehicles. Keeping your information up to date ensures your umbrella policy covers everyone in your household.

  • Overlooking Policy Exclusions: Every insurance policy has exclusions, and umbrella coverage is no different. Some people skip reading this section, only to find out later that certain activities or damages aren’t covered. Typical exclusions may include business-related claims, intentional acts, or damage caused by specific types of vehicles like boats or recreational vehicles.

    Understanding your exclusions helps you know how umbrella insurance protects your assets and what additional policies you might need to fill in the gaps.

  • Not Reviewing Your Policy After Major Life Changes: Life changes quickly, and your insurance coverage should keep up. Buying a new home, starting a business, or adding a driver to your household can all affect your coverage needs. Many people forget to update their umbrella policy, leaving them underinsured when a significant event occurs.

    Reviewing your policy at least once a year helps ensure your protection grows with your lifestyle.

Why Local Expertise from Tompkins Insurance Agencies Makes All the Difference?

Insurance laws and coverage requirements can vary significantly from one state to another. In Pennsylvania, understanding these unique rules and regional risk factors is key to choosing the proper protection. That’s why working with a local, experienced agency is so valuable.

At Tompkins Insurance Agencies, our team knows the insurance landscape in Pennsylvania inside and out. We help families and businesses select appropriate coverage limits, explain essential policy exclusions, and ensure their protection stays up to date as their needs change.

For reliable guidance on umbrella insurance in Pennsylvania, built on local experience and personal support, contact us 24/7 at 1-888-261-2688 in New York or 1-888-601-2611 in Pennsylvania today. We’re here to help you protect what matters most.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. Who should consider umbrella insurance in Pennsylvania?

    Anyone with assets, savings, or property worth protecting can benefit from Umbrella insurance in Pennsylvania.

  2. How much coverage is recommended?

    Most people choose between $1 million and $5 million, depending on their assets and financial goals.

  3. Can umbrella insurance cover legal fees?

    Yes, it typically covers legal defense costs for claims covered under your policy.

  4. Is umbrella insurance only for homeowners?

    No. Renters, business owners, and vehicle owners can also benefit from umbrella coverage.

  5. How often should I review my policy?

    It’s best to review it once a year or whenever you experience a significant change, such as buying a home or adding a vehicle.

Cyber Liability in Healthcare: Trends to Watch
Cyber Liability in Healthcare: Trends to Watch
Top Mistakes to Avoid When Buying an Umbrella Insurance Policy in Pennsylvania
Top Mistakes to Avoid When Buying an Umbrella Insurance Policy in Pennsylvania
How Pennsylvania Businesses Can Benefit from Workers’ Compensation Rate Reductions in 2025?
How Pennsylvania Businesses Can Benefit from Workers’ Compensation Rate Reductions in 2025?
Why Are Commercial Auto Insurance Costs Rising for Businesses in New York?
Why Are Commercial Auto Insurance Costs Rising for Businesses in New York?
Why Do Contractors Need General Liability Insurance in New York?
Why Do Contractors Need General Liability Insurance in New York?
Do I Really Need RV Insurance on my Travel Trailer?
Do I Really Need RV Insurance on my Travel Trailer?